CONFIDENTIAL
Hongkong.
Objection to the appointment of
...
mer Wise absence from duty we fall to the ground. It does not mean this, it will be possible for a judge to take 3 months leave and stay in the colony—though only because the appointment of an acting Judge. But I suppose Sir H.B. assumes no such case.
That "absence means in practice absence from the Colony", and that is the usual construction placed upon "absence" as to Crown Officers of this Colony is accepted. As I think it must be, it is impossible to appoint a substitute for P.J. whilst he is in the Colony, and consequently the question whether Wise can be appointed acting A.C.J. does not arise.
The words "absence" in sec 10 (2) were held to...
Its clearly cannot mean absence from duty as P.J.A.
The last-mentioned question would depend upon the construction of sec 11 of the Order. I am not quite sure of the significance of the words "not authorized by law" but the general intention of the section seems clear, and I think it precludes the appointment (whilst absent from duty).
I concur in Sir H. Berkeley's dictum.
Whatever the meaning of "absence" (and I do not think that it need or should be confined to absence from the Colony) the objection under sec 11 is fatal. I have not authorized them. Experience shows that a Judge is not a bridge to fire, nor is he required to perform duties in any other office.
...
Government House, Hongkong, 15th October, 1906.
Referring to the 2nd paragraph of my Confidential Despatch of the 9th instant in which I stated that on the retirement of Sir Henry Berkeley I was appointing Mr. A. G. Wise, Puisne Judge, to act as Attorney-General and Mr. H. H. J. Gompertz, at present serving as First Police Magistrate, to act as Puisne Judge, I have the honour to transmit a copy of a letter dated the 12th instant from Mr. Wise and of a minute dated the 15th instant from Sir Henry Berkeley, raising technical objections to the former acting temporarily in the place of the latter on his retirement.
2. I am somewhat doubtful as to the soundness of the point raised especially as it was not brought up on the previous occasion on which Mr. Wise, who was then Puisne Judge, acted as Attorney-General between the 1st April and 24th June, 1902, but in the face of so definite...
THE EARL OF ELGIN, K.G.,
&c. &c. &c.
Page 16
16 NOV OC
47030
4261430
C.P.2/7
7714
4BL
Jappee
17
Cre
Cand
Duck
8J.R. 16/11
AAA
active, P.J. Durines
ONFIDENTIA L.
Hongkong.
ofiction to the appointment of
mer Wisis absence from duty we fall to the ground. [of. it doronot mean this, it wi te possible for a judge
to take 3 months havi and stay in the colony-thonly purcative the appointment of an acting Judly. But
I suppose Sie H.B. assume
no such case
in!
оссия
that "absence medus
in
practice 7 absence from the
colore,, and that is the usual constion placed upon
persooño as to atomer of officers of this is arcepted. as I think it must be it is imporsille to appoint
for there Wiss!
-
substitute for P.Ja whilst he is in the colone, and consee, watly the question wheting with can
be appreinted acting, A.CJ docs not arios.
of absence" in six 10 (2) were held to
امام
Its clearly cannot
as P. J. A.
absante from July
the last-mentioned squestion wo? depend upon the constion
sse 11 of the order. I am not quit sure of
the
"siquifsimae of the words "not" authorized by low" but the general intention of the section steamo
and I think it precludes the appointment
__(wo strophy absent from date)
Thumpe
clear
(as acting A-G
f a P.Jas
J
Concur
LK
and in
Sir it. Berkeley's disctions.
*
his proposals for freak L.P. validative,
Whatever the meaning of absence [and
8J.R. 16/11
[ and I do not think that it need or showed be confined to absence from the
lens"
Mung
Colony of the bycation tendens §11 is fatal. Shave that not authorized them. experenal anthonger a pridge to fire perform to
Say so
no
Dover.
inter any
Cre
Cand
Duck office".
17
Jappee
4BL
C.P2.7
7714
atace
My Lord,
47030
4261430
1. 16 NOV OC
Government House,
Hongkong,15th.October,1906.
Referring to the 2nd. paragraph
of my Confidential Despatch of the 9th. instant in which I
ine Cosure tim Enol coure 2.
stated that on the retirement of Sir Henry Berkeley
I was
appointing Mr. A. G. Wise,
Puisne Judge, to act as Attor-
-ney General and Mr. H. H. J. Gompertz, at present serving
as First Police Magistrate, to act as Puisne Judge, I have
the honour to transmit a copy of a letter dated the 12th.
instant from Mr. Wise and of a minute dated the 15th.
instant from Sir Henry Berkeley, raising technical object-
-ions to the former acting temporarily in the place of the
latter on his retirement.
2.
I am somewhat doubtful as to the
soundness of the point raised especially as it was not
brought up on the previous occasion on which Mr. Wise, who
was then Puisne Judge, acted as Attorney-General between
the 1st. April and 24th. June, 1902, but in the face of so
definite
HE RIGHT HONOURABLE
THE EARL OF ELGIN, K.G.,
&C ->
&c.
&C..*
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.